Overview
The students will compare the basic roles of the federal, state
and local governments with those of their school district.
Standards — Social Studies
Grade 5
Government, Benchmark A
1. Explain major responsibilities of each of the three branches
of the U.S. government:
a. The legislative branch, headed by Congress, passes laws.
b. The executive branch, headed by the president, carries out
and enforces the laws made by Congress.
c. The judicial branch, headed by the Supreme Court, interprets
and applies the law.
Grade 8
Government, Benchmark B
6. Explain how specific provisions of the U.S. Constitution,
including the Bill of Rights, limit the powers of government in
order to protect the rights of individuals with emphasis on the
following:
a. Freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly and petition.
b. Right to trial by jury and the right to counsel.
c. Due process and equal protection of the laws.
7. Explain how the Northwest Ordinance established principles
and procedures for the orderly expansion of the United States.
Standards — Language Arts
Grade 5, Writing
Writing Process, Benchmark A
2. Conduct background reading, interviews or surveys when appropriate.
Writing Applications, Benchmark D
5. Write informational essays or reports, including research,
that organize information with a clear introduction, body and
conclusion following common expository structures when appropriate
(e.g., cause-effect, comparison-contrast) and include facts, details
and examples to illustrate important ideas.
Writing Process, Benchmark A
2. Conduct background reading, interviews or surveys when appropriate.
Research, Benchmark A
1. Generate a topic, assigned or personal interest, and open-ended
questions for research and develop a plan for gathering information.
Grade 8
Writing Process, Benchmark C
6. Organize writing with an effective and engaging introduction,
body and a conclusion that summarizes, extends or elaborates on
points or ideas in the writing.
Research, Benchmark A
1. Compose open-ended questions for research, assigned or personal
interest, and modify questions as necessary during inquiry and
investigation.
Materials
• History text
Procedure
-
Students summarize the role of each power of government (federal,
state and local) after reading history text or doing research
on the Web.
-
Review with the class the chart in this section that compares
federalism to school systems.
-
Teachers and students compile a list of interview questions
for the superintendent, the principal and a teacher regarding
the role they each play in creating and enforcing rules (laws).
For more information on interviewing, go to http://www.WesternReservePublicMedia.org/constitution/intervie.htm.
-
Students interview the superintendent, principal and teacher.
If the students do not have access to actual interviews, a variation
could be that a list of questions for the whole class can be
sent to the superintendent, principal and teacher for them to
answer in writing.
-
Students take notes based on interviews.
-
Students create a Venn diagram to compare the types of governing
bodies.
• Federal versus superintendent
• State versus principal
• Local versus teacher
Evaluation
Scoring Rubric for Venn Diagram
| CATEGORY |
4 |
3 |
2 |
1 |
| Accuracy |
The diagram is accurate. All facts are precise and explicit. |
The diagram is basically accurate. There are only a few inconsistencies
or errors in information. |
The diagram is somewhat accurate. There are more than a few
inconsistencies or errors in information. |
The diagram is completely inaccurate. The facts are misleading
to the audience. |
| Required Elements |
The diagram includes all required elements such as title,
labels, pictures and name. |
The diagram includes most of the required elements. |
Only one or two required elements are present on the Venn
diagram. |
No required elements are present on the Venn diagram. |
| Research |
The student went well above the requirements to research information.
|
The student did a good job of researching utilized materials
fully and at times took initiative to find information outside
of school. |
The student used the material provided in an acceptable manner,
but did not consult any additional sources. |
The student did not utilize resources effectively and did
little or no fact-gathering on topic. |
| Conventions |
There are no spelling, punctuation or grammatical errors.
|
There are only one or two spelling, punctuation and/or grammatical
errors present. |
There are several spelling, punctuation and/or grammatical
errors. |
There are many spelling, punctuation and/or grammatical errors. |
|