Western Reserve Public Media
 

 

Common Causes of Trauma in Children:
Placements (Foster Care, Group Home, Residential)

Eleanor Willemsen, professor of psychology at Santa Clara University, wrote, “Intimate relationships with others are the context in which we discover who we are, learn how others feel about life’s important issues and find out how to bridge differences. The emotional security and warmth derived from an initial close relationship with a loving parent provides us with a ‘home base’ from which we can venture to take the risks that are inevitably part of a life of joy and accomplishment. In short, close, psychologically intimate relationships between babies and their caregivers are central to human life.”

The question then becomes, “What happens to the individual who has these intimate relationships disrupted?” Below is some interesting information about placement options.

  • Jean-Marie Ferdion from the Institut National d’études Démographiques has found that in the United States, 34 percent of homeless young adults between the ages of 20 to 24 and 61 percent of those aged 18 to19 were in foster care at some time in their lives. She further found that the risk for young people being placed in foster care is related to the social level and poverty of the family of origin. Also, she found that “a childhood environment (natural or foster family) characterized by little emotional warmth and support or by strict discipline produces lower levels of self-esteem among adolescents.”

  • Lee Doran and Lucy Berliner, in a study of innovative practices and in ia literature review, found that multiple placements (as compared to a sustained placement) are associated with worse outcomes for children.

  • Lale Drost, in a research report, “Problems Faced by Adolescents in Group Homes,” found that problem-solving skills, such as getting advice, solving problems directly and turning to family or other adults for help, have been found to be higher in adolescents in foster families than in group home housing arrangements. He further found that group homes provide shelter for those in need, but they cannot take the place of foster parental guidance, grandparents or other family members who are willing to look after the child, nor can they replace independence for older adolescents who demonstrate the ability to take care of themselves.

 

Web Resources


 
Copyright©2005, Northeastern Educational Television of Ohio, Inc. All rights reserved.
pbs.org